- Image via Wikipedia
The hearings in the U.S. Senate have wrapped up and now we wait for the vote. President Obama is very optimistic that his nominee for the Supreme Court will win approval even though she has never served as a judge in any capacity in the past. Elena Kagan is currently the Solicitor General of the United States and is a former Dean at the Harvard Law School.
At her confirmation hearings before the Senate Judiciary Committee, Kagan promised to keep her politics separate from her judging. She says she will decide cases based on the law and not her personal feelings but some Republicans are not convinced. There are a number of conservative senators who are already on record saying they will vote against her. Senator John McCain did not like the way that she blocked military recruiting while she was Dean of the Harvard Law School and says he can’t support someone who discourages military service.
While there are a handful of senators who have said they will vote no, there are many more who say they will vote yes. They are not concerned over her lack of judicial experience and point to other great justices who did not have any experience at the time that they were named to the court like William Rehnquist. They are also quick to point out that she does have high court experience serving as a law clerk for Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall. Democrats hold a 58 to 41 seat advantage in the Senate so it would appear to be a lock that she will be approved and the question becomes how many Republicans will vote in favor of the nomination. There were eight Republicans who crossed the aisle and joined Democrats in supporting President Obama’s last high court nominee, Justice Sonia Sotomayor.










